Week 45 performance of the mutual fund
Comments: Egads - yet another rally in the last 30 minutes of a session? What is this 6 of the past 10 sessions a magical rally appears in the same time frame, during a market trending quickly down? All random chance I'm sure. This was a very interesting week; after sucking some serious wind last week the indexes were down most of the week but with the help of magic in the last 30 minutes Friday went from being down nearly 1% for the week to flat.
Magic. Get some. I need to start selling all my short exposure every day at 3:30 PM. However, under the surface a lot of damage was happening in individual names - essentially everything outside of commodities was being hit early in the first half of the week, with many stocks down 5-10%+. To wit, despite what looked
ok on the surface, in my weekly screen of winners I don't even show 10 names in the entire market that returned at least 8% this week (market capitalization $2B+). That's usually the type of performance reserved for weeks the indexes are down 4-5%. The other way to notice the weakness are the advances versus decliners each day; many days this week it was 3:7 or 4:6 winners v losers even if the overall indexes were holding up. More and more of the indexes are now being consumed by energy names, so as they gain they have masked a lot of damage elsewhere - ironically we saw that play out exactly in our portfolio with
2 names being added to the S&P 500.
While this action will allow the Goldilocks crowd to chime in that everything is fine, it appears very unhealthy to me. Markets with such narrow leadership are not something you want to see over extended periods of time, but thankfully we hold many of the leaders (to wit 3 of the 9 stocks this week which gained 8%+ are fertilizer stocks) Further, if indeed we do have a more meaningful correction from here (which according to the charts we should), we now are approaching the tricky part of our correction pattern, that we outlined a few weeks ago. First to go would be the junk sectors (they've "gone") - the
homebuilders, financials, retailers. Then we'd move on to non commodity sectors not directly correlated to the consumer (i.e. technology as an example) - that has been playing out much of this week. All that time the commodities would hold up and more and more buying power would be concentrated in those names - that has also played out. And then in the past corrective cycles, when the market finally gave in, the commodities would be the last to go and be taken to the cleaners.... just as people became complacent in these names. Lo and behold, around that time the junk would rally - and we'd sit here in the blog cursing. :) And this is the only reason I have not reloaded back up, especially in the fertilizer - which as I outlined last week were looking ready for a breakout. "The pattern" looks eerily familiar, and again - I don't want to get caught with my (Ultra) shorts down (literally?)
With
Morgan Stanley (MS) and
Goldman Sachs (GS) reporting next week (both rallied 7% Friday), we in fact could see such a pattern continue to play out as "hey its not as bad as we expected" drives these stocks up. The rumor mongers are back out again saying Goldman will report a
writedown (which they have yet to do) - if they don't that could also key a rally - while it would drive up the entire sector (and probably take retailers and
homebuilders with it), we still want to focus on the best of breed instead of buying the junk (which would rally the most only due to being beaten down the most). We saw hints of that Thursday when a lot of "poor sectors" rallied hard driven mostly by short covering in my eyes. To wit, while I still own
Ultrashort Financial (SKF) and
Ultrashort Consumer Services (SCC) I've
ratcheted them back in case we get just this move... in previous corrective episodes not only would our commodity exposure fall hard towards the end of a correction but our shorts would also work against us (since our shorts were focused on the bad sectors which rallied towards the tail end of the corrections from very beaten down levels).
This market still appears complacent to me, any half decent number is clutched to the heart ... what's that 0.6% monthly inflation? That's only 7.2% annual if it continues at that rate for a year... great! If we strip out food and energy its only 0.2% or 2.4% annual which again shows we are the only country on the globe able to not have inflation (as long as you don't eat or consume energy!). Buy stocks. Etc. Any minor happy news and I see everyone flock into technology as well since supposedly its a magical sector that is not affected by higher commodity costs - this appears to be Wall Street's latest conventional wisdom. Apparently, most of technologies customers (i.e. corporations) are going to spend spend spend, even as commodity inflation rips many apart. Another theory that will be blown to pieces down the road but for now everyone is clutching to this one like they did "this is the kitchen sink quarter in financials" last October. Anyhow, we can watch the folly and admire it in its grand foolishness but to position for such folly is the important thing. If "the pattern" plays out in a larger correction, we want to be better positioned than the last few cycles down and cut down on some of the losses. So we'll remain in our hedged position but have a more balanced short exposure across many sectors instead of focusing on "worst of breed" sectors.
For the fund, considering how much damage our #1 position (going into the week) did to us (it will remain nameless but it rhymes with
Meena Polar) I am very happy with the week's results. We actually entered the week with a 10% stake in
Meena Polar, but thankfully we chopped off some as it fell below $44, (down to a 6%
ish stake) and then the market took a lot of the stake down on its own, destroying another 1-1.5% of stake with the 20%
ish loss suffered there. Bah and humbug - yes I see she tried to save face late Friday but elephant's have a long memory. After reviewing
Meena Polar's next Q guidance it looks like they will push through another $3M in currency losses (on top of this quarter $4M ....again, while all their peers enjoy gains, the irony in it all) so that pretty much destroys any chance for a meaningful upside surprise which in the near term is what drives stocks. So instead of enjoying fruits of holding this name this Quarter, or even next Quarter, it probably is going to be 2 Quarters from now before the potential from underlying operations is seen. Sadly, I've been saying that for nearly a year now. Since time is money, we'll have to broaden into some other solar names in the meantime. It really is too bad but as I said,
Meena Polar lost its chance for glory with its "non operational decision making" - they do like to stand out of a crowd and do things no one else in the sector does. To shareholders detriment; one day I'll learn as this is the 3rd time they've done this to me.
Allright enough about that - our favorite stock and the future name of my first born helped to offset
Meena Polar - thank you
Mosaic (MOS). We also had some nice performances in
Perfect World (PWRD) and
Cummins Engine (CMI) and away we went.... again, considering the damage from 1 particular name this week, we can be content with the performance.
The fund performance versus the markets look a lot better at 3:30 PM Friday than it does at 4:00 PM Friday (market rallied 0.6% in 30 minutes) - with the invisible hand ... err random

massive buying .... in the last 30 minutes Friday, the indexes rallied to end the week basically
even (0.05% loss) in the S&P 500, and a
0.2% loss in the Russell 1000.
Rising Tide Growth, despite a back stabbing (
et tu, Meena Polar?) was able to still make up the betrayal through gains elsewhere and managed to survive with a
0.2% loss. So all in all, a nothing week - the market went nowhere, and we went nowhere.
Same Bat time, same Bat channel next week, eh? Seven more weeks to go until year 1 is officially in the books.
I'll have an update Monday on pledges; as always if interested in pledging an investment when fund is ready to launch please
attach a comment here, or send me an email (need your state please).
Price of Rising Tide Growth: $12.156
Lifetime Performance to date (
vs Aug 3, 2007): +21.56%
Comparable S&P 500: 1,360.0 (-7.18%)
Comparable Russell 1000: 746.9 (-6.19%)
Fund return vs S&P 500:
+28.7%Fund return vs Russell 1000:
+27.8%
Last week's results here.
Since the market cap of the median stock in the Rising Tide Growth fund (median $7.1 Billion as of April 08) is significantly below the SP500 index (median $13.1 Billion as of September 07) but higher than the median market cap in the Russell 1000 (median market cap $5.8 Billion as of September 07), I am measuring the fund against both indexes. Click here to see all fund's holdings as of April 2008.Basis for indexes is 5 day weighted average of closing prices Aug 3-9SP500 : 1,465.2Russell 1000 : 796.2To see why I use the 5 day weighted average of the first 5 trading days to smooth out the volatility of the indexes as the fund launched, see
here.
Please click here:
fund performance for previous updates