About 1 month ago, I wrote a piece entitled 'Analysts Still Doubting the Fertilizer Stocks'
At the time, one of my trio of fertilizer stocks, Mosaic (MOS) had just reported, with Potash (POT) set to report 2 days after the article, and then CF Industries (CF) shortly after. The theme of my article was, while these stocks had already had tremendous runs this year, analysts were still severely underestimating their future earnings potential.
However, Potash has a premium valuation for a reason; it has the most ability to expand mining production of potash - a large advantage. And with that said, after looking at how wrong the analysts have been on this sector, and how conservative they are on 2008 estimates, I think this is going to be like Apple (AAPL), where an expensive stock becomes a bit less so once we see new earnings and guidance.
Here is how far "off" the analysts were on each name (recall at the time Mosaic had reported, so analysts had pushed up their 2008 estimates significantly, whereas the other 2 names still had not reported)
Mosaic
$2.04 (90 days earlier) up to $2.94 (30 days earlier) up to $3.61 (at time of article post earnings), which is about where the estimate is now @ $3.64.
CF Industries
$3.27 (90 days earlier) up to $4.19 (30 days earlier) up to $4.93 (at time of article pre earnings), and now up to (get this) $6.66
Potash
$3.51 (90 days earlier) up to $4.02 (30 days earlier) up to $4.30 (at time of article pre earnings), and now up to $4.72
**************
With this pullback in the market, if you pull up a 1 month price chart you can see all 3 stocks trade at roughly the same price they did a month ago, despite a boatload more of earnings power coming down the pike. So all become 'cheaper' on price earnings multiple even though the stock prices are the same.
How much have 2008 estimates increased in the past 120 days?
Mosaic 78%
CF Industries 104%
Potash 35%
So while one can ask how can you continue to buy stocks that have run up so much, the data above shows the theme I keep coming back to - "pricing power" (which is another way to say "shortages"). It's a struggle for many companies now to maintain margins because they have a hard time passing along costs - ask Starbucks (SBUX). But here we have a relatively fixed cost industry, with pricing power to the extreme which means margins, margins, margins. Each incremental dollar of revenue begins to avalanche right down to the bottom line. And unlike some other industries which are a play on "global growth", I don't think there will be a huge hit to demand in this industry even if the world GDP slows significantly, especially in developing emerging markets because of the (a) urbanization trends in those countries - move 50-75M people worldwide every few years from farms to cities and you have a whole new demand dynamic (b) increased demand for more "western" foods with emphasis on "meat" which takes a lot more foodstuffs to feed and (c) global push for alternative energy sources incl. biofuels.
Now eventually new nitrogen and phosphate production will come online (most likely from, where else, China) so at "some point" in the future you will have a lot of supply online, but I keep coming back to the 1 nutrient of the bunch that a company like China cannot build 400 factories to produce, and that's potash. Much like gold or copper, you need to have a mine that has it - you can't just (over) build factories to produce it. While I am fully confidant that anything that 'can' be produced, will be 'overproduced' by the Chinese (driving down prices) in the coming years - think polysilicon in the solar space; certain things such as oil and "things that must be mined" just can't be put on the drawing board and overproduced within 2 years.
So we talk about a "wide moat" in business; what protects your competitive advantage. The 2 fertilizer producers that have emphasis on potash have the richest valuations... as they should; their moat is the strongest. As Potash just announced; it's going to take about $2 billion dollars simply to increase potash production by 15%... and they are one of the few companies in the world who actually has spare capacity. Why do they need to increase production? Well if the inventory trends are any indication... (current supply is 29% below the 5 year average). So while we hand wring as the stock prices gyrate on a daily or weekly basis, as one thinks out to what is going to survive and in fact thrive in a slower growth world economy full of new consumers with more middle class tastes - I keep coming back to this group. And this holds true if emerging markets GDP growth is 12%, 8%, 4% or 0%.
Long all 3 names in fund
Monday, November 19, 2007
Revisiting "Analysts Still Doubting the Fertilizer Stocks"
Posted by
TraderMark
at
1:04 AM
TweetThis
TweetThis
Posted by
TraderMark
at
1:04 AM
Comments (1)
| Edit This Post |
Create A New Post
Labels: CF Industries, Mosaic, Potash
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most Visited Sites
Sites I Wish I Had More Time To Read
- Newsflashr
- FinViz.com
- Zero Hedge
- Wall St Cheet Sheat
- Naked Capitalism
- Baseline Scenario
- Abnormal Returns
- TickerSpy
- Financial Armageddon
- Infectious Greed
- FT.com Alphaville.com
- 24/7 Wall Street
- The Daily Bail
- Matt Taibbi Blog
- Calculated Risk
- NYMag
- Real Clear Markets
- All About Trends
- Carpe Diem
- What's Trading
- Finz.tv
- Zentrader
- The Financial Ninja
- Daily Options Report
- Markman
- Notable Calls
- UpsideTrader
- The Smart Money Tracker
- Stock Trading to Go
- Nouriel Roubini's Blog
- Dealbreaker
- Investment Postcards
- Toro's Running of the Bulls
- Barron's Tech Trader Daily
- Market Oracle
- StraightStocks
- FINAlternatives (Hedge Funds)
- Money and Markets
- The Market Speculator
- Contrarian Profits
- Wall Street Blips
- Wall$treet Fighter
- StreetInsider Analysts News
- Blogging Stocks (AOL)
- The Daily Reckoning
- 1440 Wall Street
- HedgeFolios
- ETF Trends
- Hedge Fund Consultant Blog
- Daily Options Report
- Get Rich Slick
- Wall $treet Folly
- Guru Focus
- Fundmastery
- The Fly on the Wall
- Bill Gross PIMCO Archives
- MrSwing.com
Industry Focus Sites
- Forex Trading
- US Debt Clock
- Bloomberg Bond Yields
- List of ADRs by Country
- Mr. Copper (Kitco)
- Gas Price by State
- Mortgage Trends
- Debt Maturations
- Form 4 Oracle - Insider Filings
- Chinese Stocks
- Greentech Media
- gnuTrade
- MineWeb
- SPDR ETFs Chart
- Coal Future Pricing - Europe
- Coal Pricing - US
- Baltic Exchange Dry Index
- Solar Feeds
- The Housing Bubble
- HousingPANIC
- BusinessofVideo.com (CDNs)
Some Mutual Funds That Perk My Interest
- CGM Mutual (Kenneth Heebner)
- CGM Focus (Kenneth Heebner)
- Quaker Strategic Growth
- Loomis Sayles Mid Cap Growth
- Bridgeway Aggressive Investors
- Eaton Vance Multi Cap Growth
- Saratoga Large Cap Growth
- AFBA Five Star Large Cap
- American Century Vista
- American Century Heritage
- TCW Growth Equities
- Dynamic Power American Growth (Noah Blackstein)
- Dover Long/Short Sector Fund
Weekly Most Read
- 1: Best Performing Stock Markets by Country YTD 2009
- 2: Dennis Gartman: Gold is in a "Bubble", Meredith Whitney Just Confused
- 3: Fund Performance Period 11
- 4: Potash Could be on the Verge of a Breakout
- 5: Albert Edwards of SG Remains Firmly in Bear Camp, Calls for New Lows in 2010
- 6: George Soros Reveals Stake in Ford, Adds to Walmart, Cuts Petrobras
- 7: Time - 5 Things America Can Learn from China
- 8: WSJ - More Mutual Funds Attempt to "Time" the Market
Archives By Date
-
►
2009(1908)
-
►
11/15 - 11/22(34)
- What the Heck is Going on During Mondays Lately? A...
- NYT: With FHA Help, Easy Loans in Expensive Areas;...
- Bookkeeping: Cutting Back Perfect World (PWRD) on ...
- "Houston, We Have a (Russell 2000) Problem"
- Tim Geithner Under Fire (Videos)
- PIMCO's Bill Gross December 2009 Letter : Risk of ...
- Bookkeeping: Beginning Starter Stake in Ctrip.com ...
- More Homes in the US in Delinquency or Foreclosure...
- Bookkeeping: Selling Index Longs as S&P Breaks 110...
- John Paulson Set to Launch Gold (GLD) Hedge Fund
- Infectious Greed: Detroit v Rest of US in Unemploy...
- Toll Brothers (TOL) CEO: “Yesterday’s Subprime is ...
- Bookkeeping: Stopped Out of E-House Holdings (EJ) ...
- S&P 1100 Current Pivot Point
- Best Performing Stocks of the Decade: 1900% to 790...
- Minyanville.: Our Economy is on Steroids
- Freeport McMoran Copper & Gold (FCX) Potential Bre...
- Marc Faber: As Long as Ben Bernanke is Fed Chief, ...
- Still All Good for the Bulls - Quiet Consolidation...
- USA Today: China Pushes Solar, Wind Development
- Potash (POT) Could be on the Verge of a Breakout
- George Soros Reveals Stake in Ford (F), Adds to Wa...
- Bookkeeping: Rebuilding E-House Holdings (EJ) Posi...
- Dennis Gartman: Gold (GLD) is in a "Bubble" - Mere...
- Bookkeping: Stopped Out of E-House Holdings (EJ) S...
- It's Raining Silver (SLV)! Alleluiah!
- Interview with Andrew Horowitz of The Disciplined ...
- Time: 5 Things America Can Learn from China
- Bookkeeping: Adding to CNinsure (CISG)
- New Highs for the S&P 500; Dollar Crushed - Ground...
- Perfect World (PWRD) Beats Solidly on Earnings, Of...
- Bookkeeping: Weekly Changes to Fund Positions Year...
- Deficit Doubles for Government's Pension Benefit G...
- Updated Position Sheet
-
►
11/08 - 11/15(38)
- Sao Paulo, Shanghai, Mumbai to join New York, Lond...
- US Dollar Falls Intraday; Traders Scramble to Buy ...
- CNBC: Ron Paul - Fix the Fed (Video)
- Ordos - China's Empty City
- NYT: Rural India Gets Chance at Piece of Job Boom
- Pledge Update November 2009
- "Double Top" for Now
- Apple's (AAPL) iPhone Applications Take Root as a ...
- Wall St. Cheat Sheet Interviews Jim Rogers
- Comparing the New Claymore AlphaShares China All C...
- Same Trade as Yesterday
- WSJ: More Mutual Funds Attempt to "Time" the Marke...
- Ctrp.com (CTRP) with Impressive Earnings Report
- This Day in "Signs America is Degrading Fast": Sc...
- ► 11/01 - 11/08(38)
- ► 10/25 - 11/01(48)
- ► 10/18 - 10/25(37)
- ► 10/11 - 10/18(40)
- ► 10/04 - 10/11(35)
- ► 09/27 - 10/04(41)
- ► 09/20 - 09/27(39)
- ► 09/13 - 09/20(35)
- ► 09/06 - 09/13(32)
- ► 08/30 - 09/06(32)
- ► 08/23 - 08/30(34)
- ► 08/16 - 08/23(36)
- ► 08/09 - 08/16(39)
- ► 08/02 - 08/09(40)
- ► 07/26 - 08/02(45)
- ► 07/19 - 07/26(45)
- ► 07/12 - 07/19(45)
- ► 07/05 - 07/12(40)
- ► 06/28 - 07/05(31)
- ► 06/21 - 06/28(37)
- ► 06/14 - 06/21(44)
- ► 06/07 - 06/14(42)
- ► 05/31 - 06/07(44)
- ► 05/24 - 05/31(39)
- ► 05/17 - 05/24(33)
- ► 05/10 - 05/17(39)
- ► 05/03 - 05/10(47)
- ► 04/26 - 05/03(45)
- ► 04/19 - 04/26(43)
- ► 04/12 - 04/19(40)
- ► 04/05 - 04/12(40)
- ► 03/29 - 04/05(40)
- ► 03/22 - 03/29(45)
- ► 03/15 - 03/22(45)
- ► 03/08 - 03/15(46)
- ► 03/01 - 03/08(49)
- ► 02/22 - 03/01(49)
- ► 02/15 - 02/22(45)
- ► 02/08 - 02/15(49)
- ► 02/01 - 02/08(49)
- ► 01/25 - 02/01(49)
- ► 01/18 - 01/25(38)
- ► 01/11 - 01/18(53)
- ► 01/04 - 01/11(52)
-
►
11/15 - 11/22(34)
-
►
2008(2199)
- ► 12/28 - 01/04(27)
- ► 12/21 - 12/28(25)
- ► 12/14 - 12/21(41)
- ► 12/07 - 12/14(39)
- ► 11/30 - 12/07(34)
- ► 11/23 - 11/30(31)
- ► 11/16 - 11/23(33)
- ► 11/09 - 11/16(33)
- ► 11/02 - 11/09(33)
- ► 10/26 - 11/02(43)
- ► 10/19 - 10/26(35)
- ► 10/12 - 10/19(34)
- ► 10/05 - 10/12(38)
- ► 09/28 - 10/05(40)
- ► 09/21 - 09/28(46)
- ► 09/14 - 09/21(52)
- ► 09/07 - 09/14(49)
- ► 08/31 - 09/07(36)
- ► 08/24 - 08/31(43)
- ► 08/17 - 08/24(48)
- ► 08/10 - 08/17(50)
- ► 08/03 - 08/10(46)
- ► 07/27 - 08/03(46)
- ► 07/20 - 07/27(49)
- ► 07/13 - 07/20(48)
- ► 07/06 - 07/13(52)
- ► 06/29 - 07/06(42)
- ► 06/22 - 06/29(47)
- ► 06/15 - 06/22(41)
- ► 06/08 - 06/15(39)
- ► 06/01 - 06/08(36)
- ► 05/25 - 06/01(30)
- ► 05/18 - 05/25(39)
- ► 05/11 - 05/18(40)
- ► 05/04 - 05/11(41)
- ► 04/27 - 05/04(48)
- ► 04/20 - 04/27(44)
- ► 04/13 - 04/20(48)
- ► 04/06 - 04/13(41)
- ► 03/30 - 04/06(54)
- ► 03/23 - 03/30(41)
- ► 03/16 - 03/23(47)
- ► 03/09 - 03/16(32)
- ► 03/02 - 03/09(44)
- ► 02/24 - 03/02(54)
- ► 02/17 - 02/24(40)
- ► 02/10 - 02/17(57)
- ► 02/03 - 02/10(57)
- ► 01/27 - 02/03(49)
- ► 01/20 - 01/27(48)
- ► 01/13 - 01/20(46)
- ► 01/06 - 01/13(43)
-
▼
2007(913)
- ► 12/30 - 01/06(33)
- ► 12/23 - 12/30(29)
- ► 12/16 - 12/23(39)
- ► 12/09 - 12/16(36)
- ► 12/02 - 12/09(33)
- ► 11/25 - 12/02(44)
-
▼
11/18 - 11/25(25)
- Apple (AAPL) the Cultural Icon
- Bookkeeping: Weekly Changes to Fund Positions Week...
- Interesting Survey from Chinese Solar Companies - ...
- Bookkeeping: 'Rising Tide' Performance Week 16
- Bookkeeping: Closing Fluor (FLR)
- Bookkeeping: Temporarily Closing out GlobalSantaF...
- Is Copper Signaling a Slowing Global Economy?
- Market Erosion
- The Plan with Blue Coat Systems (BCSI)
- Deere (DE) Beats by $.34 - the Agricultural Beat G...
- What a Thanksgiving Week Rally! Some transactions...
- What a Topsy Turvy Day - Adding to 2 positions
- Bookkeeping: Closing iShares Signapore (EWS)
- Freddie Mac (FRE) and Fannie Mae (FNM) Trading Lik...
- Bookeeping: Initiating Ultrashort Xinghau China 25...
- Bookkeeping: Cutting Research in Motion (RIMM) by...
- Motley Fool on China Sunergy (CSUN)
- A Damn Shame - Blue Coat Systems (BCSI)
- Earnings on Tap pre Thanksgiving
- Initiated a new position in Gafisa (GFA) - Brazili...
- On a Positive Note....
- Another Retest of S&P 500 @ 1440
- How Much of China's "Earnings" are from Operations...
- Revisiting "Analysts Still Doubting the Fertilizer...
- Bookkeeping: Weekly Changes to Fund Positions Week...
- ► 11/11 - 11/18(44)
- ► 11/04 - 11/11(54)
- ► 10/28 - 11/04(51)
- ► 10/21 - 10/28(57)
- ► 10/14 - 10/21(55)
- ► 10/07 - 10/14(57)
- ► 09/30 - 10/07(55)
- ► 09/23 - 09/30(41)
- ► 09/16 - 09/23(41)
- ► 09/09 - 09/16(37)
- ► 09/02 - 09/09(31)
- ► 08/26 - 09/02(44)
- ► 08/19 - 08/26(43)
- ► 08/12 - 08/19(37)
- ► 08/05 - 08/12(27)









1 comments:
Amen! All we need is a sign of a turnaround in overall sentiment and these equities will fly like rockets.. ;)..
Post a Comment